Any guesses where the oldest gun store in America is located? Really, guess. Did you guess NYC? No, well, that's the claim made by the John Jovino gun shop. Do they really sell guns there? It didn't look like it to me. It looked like a dirty old surplus shop selling overpriced crap to tourists who were way eager to overpay. Either way, the place is kind of iconic and the sign/exterior has been featured in dozens of movies and TV shows. If you ever get to NYC, stop, take a photo of the outside, then just move on. That's assuming the sign hasn't fallen apart more than it already has.